There are more than 4,000 colleges and universities in the United States, ranging from open-enrollment community colleges to highly selective Ivy League institutions, from colleges with historical missions to educate the underserved to universities exploring the cutting edge of online education.
So—which college is the best in the nation?
This conflict between acknowledging the full variety of colleges—each with its own role to play and students to serve—and attempting to identify which schools are most successful at leading their graduates to fulfilling lives and careers is the core challenge that any attempt to rank colleges and universities faces. Yet despite this considerable hurdle, in recent years the number of outlets offering college rankings lists has proliferated and is likely to continue to grow as federal and state governments release more data on postsecondary institutions.
The rankings published by U.S. News & World Report were the first, arriving on newsstands in 1983. But since then, many other outlets have joined the fray, including Washington Monthly, Money magazine, The Economist, The New York Times’ Upshot, Forbes, and several others.
This conflict between acknowledging the full variety of colleges—each with its own role to play and students to serve—and attempting to identify which schools are most successful at leading their graduates to fulfilling lives and careers is the core challenge that any attempt to rank colleges and universities faces.
Yet despite this considerable hurdle, in recent years the number of outlets offering college rankings lists has proliferated and is likely to continue to grow as federal and state governments release more data on postsecondary institutions. The rankings published by U.S. News & World Report were the first, arriving on newsstands in 1983. But since then, many other outlets have joined the fray, including Washington Monthly, Money magazine, The Economist, The New York Times’ Upshot, Forbes, and several others.
Indeed, in 2013 President Obama announced that the U.S. Department of Education would produce its own system for rating higher education institutions, though notably this proposed effort would only have given colleges a score, not rank them as the media lists do. But after nearly two years of discussions with college administrators and researchers, the department decided not to produce ratings, opting instead just to release more data about these institutions, including the average salary for students 10 years after they enrolled.
The department’s decision to abandon its ratings proposal, after facing criticism from many parts of the higher education community, demonstrates how challenging it can be to measure a college’s performance and the consequences that a particular rating or ranking could have for that institution. The federal agency originally sought to use the ratings as a tool for holding colleges more accountable, perhaps even tying an institution’s students’ eligibility to receive financial aid to how well the school performed by the Education Department’s measures. But, for example, if a college’s graduation rate becomes a key part of the rating, would two-year colleges or other institutions with high transfer rates receive unfavorable ratings?
Even though colleges and universities typically do not face any direct accountability for their ranking in the lists published by media outlets, these rankings are widely considered to have substantial impact on the ways some postsecondary institutions operate, as they seek more favorable rankings. From which types of students they seek to enroll to how they allocate their financial resources for faculty and campus development, administrators and trustees often have to consider how important a rise or fall on the list might be to the their institutions’ reputations and revenue.
Journalists should approach writing about college rankings and ratings with insight that goes beyond the rank or score a college received—and whether it’s up or down this year—to offer analysis on how and why the institution measured up that way in that particular list. The best way to achieve these deeper insights is to explore the data used to create the ranking. Most college rankings start with the data available publicly through the National Center for Education Statistics, the federal organization that collects and analyzes these numbers.
There is a wealth of information available from this resource, but journalists should note that for each institution, the reported data are only for students who were first-time, full-time enrollees in college. This means that for institutions that enroll many adults who are returning to school (e.g. community colleges) or accept many transfer students (regional public universities), the NCES data might not be the most accurate representation of how well the college is serving its students. This note of caution is particularly relevant for the data regarding graduation and retention rates.
College rankings increasingly are using data that reflect the earning potential of students at each institution. In the fall of 2015, the College Scorecard the federal government produces for the first time added data for the average income for students at each college 10 years after they enrolled. These data are a boon for researchers, rankers, journalists, and—of course—students and families. It should be noted, however, that these data are for all students who enrolled that year, regardless of whether they graduated.
For colleges in which many students drop out or transfer before earning a degree, the earnings number reported on the Scorecard is likely lower than it might be for actual graduates of that institution. These scorecard data also are for the institution overall, not program-by-program, so reporters should examine whether the college produces many graduates in science, engineering, or business disciplines, for instance, that might be tipping the scales.
Several state education departments do gather earnings data at the program level for colleges and universities in their borders. Check with your department to see whether it collects such data that you might use to cross-check what you see listed in rankings.
When reporting about rankings, also look to see whether the publisher gathers any proprietary data. For example, U.S. News & World Report each year commissions a survey of the top administrators of every college in an effort to measure each institution’s reputation. And, on the opposite end, the Princeton Review surveys more than 100,000 college students across the country each year to find the nation’s best party schools and least happy students.
#smartstudentserp #1 erp software #1 erp solutions #5 college risk management #business management #campus asset management #campus management #campus management 2018 #campus management Chennai #campus management development #campus management india #campus management international #campus management pricing #campus management products #campus management reviews #campus management software india #campus management solution #campus management support #campus management system #campus management system software #campus management tool #campus traffic management #campus travel management #campus view management #campus waste management #category in erp #college attendance management system #college bus management system #college estate management #college facilities management #college faculty management system #college fee management software free download #college for management #college for management and business #college health management #college hospitality management #college hotel management #college leave management system #college library management software free download #college library management system #college management #college management accounts #college management app #college management committee #college management database system #college management definition #college management erp #college management erp software #college management free software #college management information system #college management report #college management rules #college management software #college management structure #college management system #college of management and technology #college quality management system #college result management system #college risk management #college sports management group #college sports management jobs #college time management #college time management app #define a school management #e school management system #erp #erp 2018 #erp accounting systems #erp administrator #erp analysts #erp applications #erp business analyst #erp calculator #erp certificate #erp consultant #erp consultant salary #erp dashboard #erp databases #erp definition #erp design #erp exam #erp examples #erp for small business #erp full form #erp home #erp industry #erp jobs #erp keywords #erp knowledge #erp login #erp logo #erp market #erp meaning #erp modules #erp names #erp operating systems #erp options #erp packages #erp sap #erp software #erp solutions #erp specialist #erp system #erp system definition #erp systems #erp systems examples #erp technologies #erp test #erp tools #erp university #erp website #e-school management software #e-school management system #e-school management system documentation #free school management system #k-12 erp systems #k-12 school management software #k-12 school management system #levels of school management #primary school management #primary school management system #private school management #problems with school management #relationship with school management #sap vs erp #school based management 2018 #school library management #school library management software #school management #school management and administration #school management and daily operations #school management and operational systems #school management apps #school management books #school management brochure #school management committee #school management companies #school management dashboard #school management database #school management definition #school management demo #school management development committee #school management features #school management for teachers #school management free download #school management free software #school management free software downloads #school management functions #school management icon #school management images #school management in education #school management information system #school management information system india #school management issues #school management letter #school management login #school management logo #school management manual #school management mobile app #school management mobile application #school management modules #school management notes #school management portal #school management problems and solutions #school management program #school management question paper #school management questionnaire #school management quotations #school management record #school management records #school management report #school management requirements #school management software india #school management software price list #school management system #tally erp #tally erp 7 #tally erp 7.2 free download #the school management #the school management structure #the school management team #top 5 management college
No comments:
Post a Comment